
As they go home, Aphrodite angrily informs Zoey that "it's not over yet – you don't understand." Neferet, who happens to witness everything, takes Aphrodite's status as leader of the Dark Daughters and Sons and gives it to Zoey instead. Zoey steps in she and her friends use their newfound abilities to stop the spirits. Aphrodite accidentally summons evil spirits which try to take Heath's fresh human blood.

Everything goes fine until sobered up Heath stumbles upon the scene and tries to bring Zoey back with him. Zoey is (spitefully) invited back to the Dark Daughters and Sons' Samhain celebration, where they honor the spirits with some blood. Stevie Rae, Damien, Shaunee, and Erin each gain an affinity for one element as well. Zoey discovers that she has affinities for the five elements of air, fire, earth, water, and spirit – something that has never happened before in vampyre history. As it is very unusual that Zoey could create an Imprint in her first month of being a "vampyre", she places Zoey into a senior vampyre sociology course. The following day, she meets Neferet, who explains to her that an Imprint is a link that takes place between an adult vampyre and his or her human Consort. That night she is chosen by a cat, whom she names Nala. He comforts her and escorts her back to the dorm. When they have gone, Zoey discovers that Erik Night, a handsome fifth former and Dark Son whom she met earlier, has seen the whole scene. Kayla freaks out and runs away Zoey eventually persuades Heath to leave too. She scratches Heath and drinks from the wound, creating an Imprint with him. An angry confrontation ensues with her now ex-best friend and Zoey loses control. Zoey stumbles upon them while Kayla is hitting on Heath. Embarrassed, she flees – but finds Heath, her ex-boyfriend, and Kayla, her best friend, who have come to the school in an attempt to bust Zoey out. During the ritual, Aphrodite feeds her fledgling blood and Zoey discovers a new craving, unusual for her age. Her new friends counsel her to accept so that they can get insight into Aphrodite's doing's. To humiliate Zoey she invites her to join the Dark Daughters, who are an elitist group. She also meets the snobby, beautiful leader of the Dark Daughters and Sons, Aphrodite, a fledgling with the power to see the future. Through Stevie Rae, Zoey meets and befriends Damien, Erin, and Shaunee. Aphrodite, another fledgling then takes her to her room, where she meets Stevie Rae, her new roommate and, future best friend. As a fledgling vampyre, Zoey has the opportunity to change her name and does so, taking her grandmother's surname, Redbird, before parting with her. She finds out that her Mark is all filled in, unusually for fledglings, but follows her intuition and doesn't mention the vision to Neferet. Zoey wakes up at the school in the presence of her grandmother and the vampyre headmaster – her future mentor, Neferet.

The goddess leaves Zoey with the words "Darkness does not always equate to evil, Light does not always bring good" which becomes a very frequent and important message throughout the series. On the way, she passes out and has a vision with the vampyre goddess, Nyx, who announces to Zoey that she will be her "eyes and ears" at the House of Night. As fledglings need to be constantly in the presence of an adult vampyre so that their bodies won't reject the Change, Zoey flees to her grandmother Sylvia, a Cherokee Wise Woman. Her mother, Linda Heffer, blames her for the Mark and, together with her ultra-religious husband (Zoey's stepfather/step-loser), she tries to keep Zoey at home, to be presented to the Elders of the People of Faith, an anti-vampyre group. She gets stopped outside in the parking lot by her boyfriend Heath, and his friends who call her a freak and drive away.

One day, during school, Zoey is marked by a Tracker to become a fledgling vampyre at the Tulsa House of Night, a boarding school where she will be trained to become an adult vampyre. Sixteen-year-old Zoey Redbird lives in a world where vampires, or "vampyres" have always existed.
